I've had a number of clients sail the Paul Gauguin more than once, and the question of loyalty perks comes up every time. My take is simple: the returning-guest benefits are a nice bonus, not a reason to book by themselves. The ship only carries around 330 guests, so the line tends to remember repeat travellers in ways that don't show up on a points statement. Here's how I'd actually weigh it.
What returning guests tend to get
Repeat cruisers usually see onboard recognition, the odd booking credit or amenity, and small touches the crew extends to people they've sailed with before. The specific structure and any tiers change over time, so I always tell clients to confirm the current returning-guest benefits when they book rather than rely on what was offered a few years back.

Why the small-ship size matters more
On a 330-guest ship the staff genuinely learn your name, your table preference, how you take your coffee. The Tahitian hosts, Les Gauguines, and the dining team make the second sailing feel different from the first in a way no loyalty tier really captures. For most of my clients that personal continuity is the real reward.
How I'd factor it into a decision
I never tell someone to pick a sailing purely to chase a perk. Choose the itinerary and dates that suit you first; treat any returning-guest benefit as a small thank-you on top. If you're close to a threshold that unlocks something worthwhile, it's worth a quick check with whoever you book through.

Frequently asked questions
Does Paul Gauguin reward repeat guests?
Yes, returning guests typically receive onboard recognition and occasional credits or amenities. The exact benefits change over time, so confirm the current program when booking.
Is it worth booking just for loyalty perks?
In my view, no. Pick the itinerary and dates that suit you; treat any returning-guest benefit as a bonus rather than the deciding factor.
Do perks make a big difference on board?
The bigger difference is the ship's small size — around 330 guests — which lets the crew remember repeat travellers personally, beyond any formal program.
Planning a Paul Gauguin voyage? Tell us your dates and what you're dreaming of and we'll map it out for you.